Bad Leadership


    Jeremiah 23
















Even though the book of Malachi is always associated with robbing God and the tithes and offerings, the book is really about relationship. The tithes and offerings are simply an expression or evidence of that relationship or lack thereof. Being that the first thing addressed in Malachi is the loss of relationship, that’s where we’ll begin.

Relationship is extremely important to God, in fact it’s everything to Him. He goes on give the example of marriage in chapter 2 to highlight this fact (more on marriage in another post). For now, who is God talking to and really addressing? The leaders. When God is asking His questions it is the leaders who are responding. Sure it could also be the people too, and probably is to some degree, but it’s the leaders who are ultimately responsible for the condition of the people so God is addressing them and holding them accountable.



A great example of how leadership and responsibility work, let’s take a look at the military. To keep it simple, a company in the army is often lead by a captain, under him are lieutenants, sergeants, and privates, this is the chain of command. A company is broken down into platoons lead by sergeants. If a sergeant is given a mission to perform with his platoon it comes down from the captain through the chain of command to the sergeant. The sergeant then gives orders to the rest of the soldiers in the platoon. If the mission fails who is responsible, the private or sergeant who were both on the mission? Before the answer, let’s develop this a bit further in order to really illustrate this point. A captain is often overseen by a Colonel in charge of several companies, the failed mission reaches the Colonel’s desk. Who does the Colonel hold responsible? If you said the Captain, you’re right, because the Captain is responsible for everyone under him; his lieutenants, sergeants, and privates. He cannot just point the finger and say “they did it”. He must ultimately take responsibility for the failed mission because he is responsible for their training, actions, and conduct. The same goes for the lieutenants, sergeants, down to the private, who is responsible for his actions. If anyone in this line did exactly as he was told to do the responsibility falls on the one who gave the order. God works in this same way, so He is addressing and holding responsible the leaders for their condition and condition of His people. In other words, starting at the top, leadership is examined and appropriate action taken when fault is found.  The process then continues down the chain of command all the way to the end. The only time a leader it is not responsible is when they have carried out the orders they were given and after examination they have been found to have done all they can, that circumstances were out of their control and have been found blameless. Does this mean the people are off the hook? Nooooooo! Just as the private is responsible for his actions, so are we to varying degrees based on the level of training and responsibility as we will see. This system of accountability can be applied to all areas of leadership including marriage which God just happens to bring up.  And because God devised this system He is subject to it too and subjects Himself to his own standards prior to any judgment. God first looks in the mirror to examine Himself, and only after being found clean moves on to the next phase; otherwise God would be a hypocrite. A great leader will never ask anyone under him to do something they are not willing to do, can’t do, or have never done. Also any leader that blames his subordinates for not knowing something is a bad leader unless they have done all they can to teach and train. That’s like a teacher who blames their students for not learning when in fact they are the ones who have failed. What we need to remember and take away from this is that it all starts with leadership, and that’s the way God wants it.

The book of Malachi definitely highlights the affects of bad leadership. God mentions the need to purify the Levites which were the leaders at that time. God even laments the loss of good leadership by remembering the past and how things were with Levi. He also comments about how things are (at that time) and the bad influence the leaders are having on the people by not teaching them correctly, misguiding the people, by their bad teaching actually instructing the people to offend God, and driving them away. This subject matter demands our attention. Do any of our leaders today exhibit any of the same traits they did then?

So if the leadership at that time were the Levites or Priests, today’s equivalent would be our pastors primarily, which scripturally are shepherds; does God have any more to say about leadership, particularly bad leadership? Why yes, yes He does! Enter Jeremiah 23, Ezekiel 34, and Zechariah 11. 

In Jeremiah 23 God addresses the shepherds, priests, and prophets (leadership). As we read this keep Malachi in mind.


Verse 1 “Woe to the shepherds who are destroying and scattering My sheep!” says the Lord. 2 the Lord says against the shepherds who tend My people: “You have scattered My flock, driven them away, and you have not attended to them. Behold, I am about to deal with you for your evil deeds,” – The shepherds are destroying and killing by NOT taking care of the people physically and/or spiritually. Scattering/driving away is literal in the passage but not necessarily today. Today it’s more spiritual in nature, scattering or driving toward other gods or just away from God. Notice the contrast in verse 2, some of their evil deeds or actions are things they are NOT doing (commission vs omission). “You have not attended to them” is directly related to the tithes and offerings because that is what the tithes and offerings are for and how they are to be used. The leaders in Malachi were guilty of all of the above.

We skip down to verse 11 “Both the prophets and priests are profane; I have found their wickedness in My house,” says the Lord. – Profane means to be defiled or polluted. There are two primary ways to profane or defile one’s self; the obvious is by clearly doing the wrong things, the other by not doing what should be done. In this case both prophet and priest are profane because they are guilty of both, engaging in evil behavior and not performing their respective duties and hurting the people. “In My house”, where this is taking place (Lev 21:4, 22:2, 9, 15, 32, Num 12:7, 2 Sam 7:5, 1 Kings 5:5, Isa 56:5, Jer 7:9-11, 23:11, Ezek 44:10-12)

13 “I have seen the foolishness in the prophets of Samaria: for they prophesied by Baal and caused My people to err. 14 I have also seen horrible things in the prophets of Jerusalem: they commit adultery and walk in lies; they also strengthen the hands of the wicked, so that no one turns back from his evil ways. All of them are like Sodom to Me, and her inhabitants like Gomorrah. – Any time you see prophets, priests, shepherds, Levites, or anything like this think leadership. We read “prophesied by Baal”, “commit adultery”, “walk in lies”, and “strengthen the hands of the wicked”; besides the obvious, prophesying for other gods, lying, “strengthen the hands of the wicked” is to show partiality, approve of, encourage, and bless them. “Like Sodom to Me” and “like Gomorrah” not in a physical sense but rather they are prideful, gluttonous, lazy, and selfish (Ezek 16:49). We also have the tendency to think that we or our leaders don’t do any of those things, so this doesn’t pertain to me/us. Well, it does, it doesn’t have to be those exact things to be bad or horrible (Rom 2:11-13, James 2:10, 3:1). However if we are honest I think we will discover that the same offenses are indeed happening; prophesying by ourselves resulting in and equivalent to lying, and strengthening the hand of the wicked by not confronting. We often get caught up in the literal reading and miss the real message.


16 “Do not listen to the prophets who prophesy to you.” Says the Lord, “They make you worthless; they tell you a vision of their own heart, not from the mouth of the Lord. 17 They say to those that despise Me, ‘The Lord has said, “You will have peace”’; and to all those who walk according to the dictates of their own heart, they say, ‘No evil will befall you.’” – We are not to listen to bad, false, or ungodly leaders, teachers or pastors (1 Tim 6:5, 2 Tim 3:5, 4:3, Rev 2:14-15). ”They make us worthless” (Mal 1:10). “They tell you a vision of their own heart” setting themselves up as God and doing what is right in their own eyes (Deut 12:8, Pr 12:15, 21:2).  Of course, spotting these leaders and not following them takes spiritual discernment (1 John 4:1).

20 The Lord’s anger will not cease until He has executed and performed all the thoughts of His heart. In the last days you will understand perfectly. – We can understand now (maybe these are the last days?). . . He’s upset and He will not stop the correction until they are purified and cleansed (Jer 7:9-11, 11:9-11, Ezek 39:22-24). Many have a hard time understanding how God can do this to His own people. It’s His righteousness and holiness that demand it. Also, we need to keep in mind that they/we have already left Him and His ways, and that they/we are already outside of His will and protection. God doesn’t leave first, we do. And, that His motivation is love and restoration, He wants them/us to come back, He wants the relationship restored.

22 But if they had only stood in My counsel, and had caused My people to hear Me and My word, they would have turned them from their evil ways and from their evil deeds. 23 “Am I a God close and near at hand,” says the Lord, “And not a God far away? 24 Can anyone hide himself from Me in a secret place, so I cannot see him? Do I not fill the heavens and earth?” declares the Lord. – “evil ways” are simply not godly, doing things that shouldn’t be done and not doing things that should be (2 Kings 17:13, 2 Chronicles 7:14, Jer 4:18, 18:11). “Can anyone hide”, El Roi (the God who sees)

29 “Is not My word like a blazing fire?” says the Lord,
“And like a hammer that breaks rock into pieces? – “Will My word not accomplish what it is sent out to do?” (Is 55:11)









31 Behold, I am against the prophets,” declares the Lord, “who use their place and say, ‘He says.’ 32  Behold, I am against those who have prophesied made up dreams,” says the Lord, “ to cause My people to err by their lies and carelessness. Yet I did not send them or command them; therefore they will not benefit this people at all,” says the Lord. – Translation = “I am against those leaders that speak for Me when I haven’t spoken, for prophesying dreams and visions that I have not given them, misguiding My people; they do not speak for Me or represent Me and they are no good for you.”

39 therefore behold, I, even I, will utterly forget you and forsake you, and the city that I gave you and your fathers, and will cast you out of My presence. 40 And I will bring an everlasting reproach upon you, and a perpetual shame, which shall not be forgotten.’” – All through scripture God reveals Himself a forgiving God full of second chances, and as long as there is even the slightest bit of humility, love, or openness, God is more than willing to extend and grant us the forgiveness we need. But there comes a time, not when God is not willing, but when we are not willing and we go too far, and our hearts are seared closed, forever separating us from Him (1 Tim 4:2).

To sum up, the leaders are destroying, scattering, and driving the sheep away by not attending to them (not meeting needs), speaking for other gods (even themselves), misguiding, misleading the people, and lying; they are proud (arrogant, stubborn), gluttonous (consuming), lazy (don’t want to do their duty and do they even know it?), selfish, God is against them (opposed to their ways), and punishment/correction is coming. Ok, that about covers it.


Whaaaaat?! Do we even understand what we just read?! There is so much going on here than what meets the eye.  








These verses are so powerful it would be a shame for us and especially our leaders to simply dismiss any of what these passages have to say because of pride, embarrassment, or an unwillingness to look in the mirror. 


It is leadership that is supposed to be the most teachable, the most humble, the chief servants and setting an example for the rest of the family. 






After all it is God that told us that a man looks in the mirror then walks away forgetting what manner of man he is (James 1:23-24). Well, welcome to the mirror. Let us not fulfill the last half of this passage.

To contrast these verses let’s see what good shepherds/leaders would have and should have been doing – giving life and attending to the people by meeting physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual needs, thereby gathering and calling the people to them and God, and speaking God’s words keeping people on the path. They would have been faithful, speaking truth, rebuking and confronting the wicked turning them from their ways, and a humble servant that God is for and will remember.






The Malachi Blessing
themalachiblessing.blogspot.com
themalachiblessing@gmail.com

No comments:

Post a Comment